Be sure to shake before use. Doesn't transfer in the crease. Definitely waterproof - survives crying. Not sad or anything, my eyes just like to tear up when I do heavy makeup ^^;;

All very well. The only thing arriving via Spain in two months. The rest is very happy. Good quality. Draw well. I don't know how to erase. No strange smells. Thanks to the seller

just like described , the line is clean and dark . we doesn't go off with water . however , it is easy to wipe. but doesn't leave a black smudge. i recommend this product.

The black one has a great tip. However the white one isn't eyeliner. It's an eyeshadow pencil. I'm very happy with the purchase. Shipped within a month.

Got the one in the cover listing (gold and black packaging) and works well, doesn’t smear when rubber just kinda falls off which I prefer.